Unfortunately none of these had the Sherlock Holmes magic, and today the stories seem hopelessly artificial and contrived.Ĭhesterton said as much at the time. A host of Holmes-like sleuths soon appeared, each with his own series of linked short stories. It was the greatest success in magazine publishing history.Ĭonan Doyle’s triumph was not lost on The Strand’s competitors. Conan Doyle aimed to compete against the serialized novel with a character whose fascinating personal appeal-rather than a continuing cliff-hanger plot-would keep readers coming back for more. The sleuth then reappears in subsequent magazine stories to solve other puzzling crimes.Īrthur Conan Doyle perfected this approach with his tales of the peerless Sherlock Holmes, written for The Strand magazine in the 1890s. The mystery deepens until the eccentric but brainy sleuth (not a member of the official police) deduces the truth and reveals the surprising solution at the story’s conclusion. The formula, invented by Edgar Allan Poe in the 1840s, boils down to this:Ī mystifying crime is discovered, and a plausible explanation proves elusive. The Father Brown stories follow a format developed in the nineteenth century for readers of the new mass-circulation magazines. They often fail to appreciate Chesterton’s work within the framework of this literary form. Similarly, few students of Chesterton are mystery story enthusiasts, and fewer still are conversant with scholarship on the detective genre. These critics react to Chesterton’s moral and political ideas as if they were an intrusion of irrelevant propaganda. For example, not many who are experts in the field of detective fiction understand Chesterton as a philosopher. Part of the problem is that Chesterton’s stories resist analysis from the specialist’s point of view. Truly, these critics are so at odds with one another that often they do not seem to be discussing the same stories. Yet after literally hundreds of commentators have had their say, there is still no consensus about what his achievement was or in what ways Father Brown is significant. NEARLY EVERYONE AGREES that Chesterton achieved something extraordinary with his Father Brown stories.

The annotated innocence of father brown